Usak University

Published 2018-11-29

How to Cite

AYDIN, E., & ÖZEREN, E. (2018). RETHINKING WORKFORCE DIVERSITY RESEARCH THROUGH CRITICAL PERSPECTIVES: EMERGING PATTERNS AND RESEARCH AGENDA. Business & Management Studies: An International Journal, 6(3), 650–670. https://doi.org/10.15295/bmij.v6i3.393


This paper aims at highlighting the theoretical development of diversity management by providing an integrated understanding of how diversity management has made progress and evolved in organisations. The current article adopts a conceptual and critical review to demonstrate the changes and shifts in diversity management research. This study reveals that there are four stages of workforce diversity within the business and management field. These stages are equal employment opportunity/affirmative action, valuing differences, diversity management and global diversity management. Each stage is discussed in greater details within the article. This study contributes to the broader diversity management literature in three main ways: firstly, by shedding some light on the conceptual clarity of the diversity notion itself; secondly, by foregrounding the holistic view of diversity management; thirdly, by reflecting the recent developments in diversity research. The review consistently points to the fact that the current literature on diversity management has been predominantly shaped by a mainstream managerial discourse and neoliberal logic which has mostly a discrimination focus rather than an inclusiveness perspective. The paper also suggests that further research is required on workforce diversity particularly with an emic, an intersectional, a contextual and a relational approach rather than reproducing the existing knowledge by an etic framing of diversity from an instrumental point of view that dominates the extant literature.


Download data is not yet available.


  1. Acker, J. (2006), “Inequality regimes: Gender, class and race in organizations”, Gender & Society, 20(4), 441-464.
  2. Adib, A. and Guerrier, Y. (2003), “The Interlocking of Gender with Nationality, Race, Ethnicity and Class: The Narratives of Women in Hotel Work”, Gender Work and Organization 10(4), 413–32.
  3. Ahonen, P., Tienari, J., Meriläinen, S. and Pullen, A. (2014), “Hidden contexts and invisible power relations: A Foucauldian reading of diversity research”. Human Relations, 67(3), 263-286
  4. Bajawa, A. and Woodall, J. (2006), “Equal opportunity and diversity management meet downsizing: a case study in the UK airline industry”, Employee Relations, 28(1), 46-61.
  5. Baker, D.L., Schmaling, K., Fountain, K.C., Blume, A.W. and Boose, R. (2016), “Defining diversity: A mixed method analysis of terminology in faculty applications”, The Social Science Journal, 53(1), 60-66.
  6. Boxenbaum, E. (2006), “Lost in translation the making of danish diversity management”, American Behavioral Scientist, 49(7), 939-948.
  7. Bridgstock, R., Lettice, F., Ozbilgin, M.F. and Tatli, A. (2010), “Diversity management for innovation in social enterprises in the UK. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development”, 22 (5), 1–18.
  8. Casey, M. (2004), “De-dyking queer space(s): heterosexual female visibility in gay and lesbian spaces”, Sexualities, 7(4), 446–461.
  9. Charles, J. (2003), “Diversity management: An exploratory assessment of minority group representation in state government”, Public Personnel Management, 32(4), 561-577.
  10. Collins, H. and Wray-Bliss, E. (2000), “Equal Opportunities Policies: The Authority of Discrimination”, Management Research News, 23(9/10/11), 39-41.
  11. Cornelius, N., Gooch, L. and Todd, S. (2001), “Managing difference fairly: an integrated ‘partnership’approach”, in Noon, M. and Ogbonna, E. (eds.) Equality, diversity and disadvantage in employment. Basingstoke: Palgrave, pp. 32-50.
  12. Cox, L.G. and Simpson, A. (2015), “Cultural safety, diversity and the servicer user and carer movement in mental health research”, Nursing inquiry, 22(4), 306-316.
  13. Day, N. E. and Greene, P. G. (2008), “A case for sexual orientation diversity in small and large organizations”. Human Resource Management, 47(3), 637–654.
  14. Dreachslin, J.L. (2007), “Diversity management and cultural competence: Research, practice, and the business case”, Journal of Healthcare Management, 52(2), 79-86.
  15. Embrick, D. G., Walther, C. S. and Wickens, C. M. (2007), “Working class masculinity: Keeping gay men and lesbians out of the workplace”, Sex Roles, 56(11-12), 757-766.
  16. Ensari, N.K. and Miller, N. (2006), “The application of the personalization model in diversity management”, Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 9(4), 589-607.
  17. Gardenswartz, L. and Rowe, A. (1998), “Why diversity matters”, Hr Focus, 75(7),1-3.
  18. Gilbert, J.A. and Ivancevich, J.M. (2000), “Valuing diversity: A tale of two organizations”, The Academy of Management Executive, 14(1), 93-105.
  19. Gilbert, J.A., Stead, B.A. and Ivancevich, J.M. (1999), “Diversity management: A new organizational paradigm”, Journal of Business Ethics, 21(1), 61-76.
  20. Holvino, E. (2010), “Intersections: the simultaneity of race, gender and class in organization studies”, Gender, Work & Organization, 17(3), 248-277.
  21. Holvino, E. and Kamp, A. (2009), 'Diversity management: Are we moving in the right direction? Reflections from both sides of the North Atlantic', Scandinavian Journal of Management, 25(4), 395-403.
  22. Hoque, K. and Noon, M. (2004), “Equal opportunities policy and practice in Britain: evaluating the ‘empty shell’hypothesis”, Work, Employment & Society, 18(3), 481-506.
  23. Humphries, M. and Grice, S. (1995), “Equal employment opportunity and the management of diversity: a global discourse of assimilation?”, Journal of Organizational Change Management, 8(5), 17-32.
  24. Jewson, N. and Mason, D. (1986), “The theory and practice of equal opportunities policies: liberal and radical approaches”, The Sociological review, 34(2), 307-334.
  25. Johnson, D.W. and Johnson, F.P. (2014), Joining together: Group theory and group skills . 11th edn. UK: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
  26. Johnston, W.B. and Packer, A.E. (1987), Workforce 2000: Work and workers for the twenty-first century. Indianapolis: DIANE Publishing.
  27. Jonsen, K., Maznevski, M. L. and Schneider, S. C. (2011), “Special Review Article: Diversity and its not so diverse literature: An international perspective”, International Journal of Cross Cultural Management, 11(1), 35 -62.
  28. Joshi, A. and Roh, H. (2009), “The role of context in work team diversity research: A meta-analytic review”. Academy of Management Journal, 52(3), 599-627.
  29. Kaler, J. (2001), “Diversity, equality, morality”, in Noon, M. and Ogbonna, E. (eds.) Equality, diversity and disadvantage in employment. Basingstoke: Palgrave, pp. 51-64.
  30. Kalev, A., Dobbin, F. and Kelly, E. (2006), “Best practices or best guesses? Assessing the efficacy of corporate affirmative action and diversity policies”, American Sociological Review, 71(4), 589-617.
  31. Kandola, R.S. and Fullerton, J. (1994), Managing the mosaic: Diversity in action. Institute of Personnel and Development.
  32. Kellough, J. E. and Naff, K. C. (2004), “Managing diversity in the federal service: Responding to a wake-up call”. Administration & Society, 36(1), 62-90.
  33. Kersten, A. (2000), “Diversity management: Dialogue, dialectics and diversion”, Journal of Organizational Change Management, 13(3), 235-248.
  34. Kirton, G. and Greene, A. (2010), “'What does diversity management mean for the gender equality project in the United Kingdom? Views and experiences of organizational “actors”, Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences/Revue Canadienne des Sciences de l'Administration, 27(3), 249-262.
  35. Kirton, G. and Greene, A. (2015), The dynamics of managing diversity: A critical approach. Routledge.
  36. Konrad, A.M. and Linnehan, F. (1995), “Formalized HRM structures: coordinating equal employment opportunity or concealing organizational practices?”, Academy of Management Journal, 38(3), 787-820.
  37. Lawrence, E. (2000), “Equal opportunities officers and managing equality changes”, Personnel Review, 29(3), 381-402.
  38. Liff, S. (1997), “Two routes to managing diversity: individual differences or social group characteristics”, Employee Relations, 19(1), 11-26.
  39. Liff, S. and Wajcman, J. (1996) '‘Sameness’ and ‘difference’revisited: which way forward for equal opportunity initiatives?', Journal of Management Studies, 33(1), 79-94.
  40. Litvin, D.R. (1997), “The discourse of diversity: From biology to management”, Organization, 4(2), 187-209.
  41. Litvin, D.R., Konrad, A. and Pringle, J. (2006), “Making space for a better case”, in Prasad, P., Prongle, J. And Konrad, A. (eds.) Handbook of Workplace Diversity. London: Sage, pp. 75-94.
  42. Lorbiecki, A. and Jack, G. (2000), “Critical turns in the evolution of diversity management”, British Journal of Management, 11(1), 17-31.
  43. Mavin, S. and Girling, G. (2000), “What is managing diversity and why does it matter?”, Human Resource Development International, 3(4), 419-433.
  44. Maxwell, G. A., Blair, S., and McDougall, M. (2001), “Edging towards managing diversity in practice”. Employee relations, 23(5), 468-482.
  45. Maxwell, G., McDougall, M., Blair, S. and Masson, M. (2003), “Equality at work in UK public-service and hotel organizations: inclining towards managing diversity?”, Human Resource Development International, 6(2), 243-258.
  46. McCall, L. (2005), “The Complexities of Intersectionality”, Signs, 30(3), 1771–800.
  47. McDermott, E. (2006). “Surviving in dangerous places: lesbian identity performances in the workplace, social class and psychological health”, Feminism & Psychology, 16(2), 193-211.
  48. McDonald, D.M. (2010), “The Evolution of ‘Diversity Management’in the USA: Social Contexts, Managerial Motives and Theoretical Approaches”, Institute of Business Research, Daito Bunka University.
  49. Morrison, M., Lumby, J. and Sood, K. (2006), “Diversity and diversity management messages from recent research”, Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 34(3), 277-295.
  50. Nishii, L.H. and Özbilgin, M.F. (2007), “Global diversity management: towards a conceptual framework”, The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 18(11), 1883-1894.
  51. Nkomo, S. and Hoobler, J.M. (2014), “A historical perspective on diversity ideologies in the United States: Reflections on human resource management research and practice”, Human Resource Management Review, 24(3), 245-257.
  52. Noon, M. (2007), “The fatal flaws of diversity and the business case for ethnic minorities”. Work, employment and society, 21(4), 773-784.
  53. Ollapally, A. and Bhatnagar, J. (2009), “The holistic approach to diversity management: HR implications', Indian Journal of Industrial Relations”, 454-472.
  54. Olzak, S. and Ryo, E. (2007), “Organizational diversity, vitality and outcomes in the civil rights movement”, Social Forces, 85(4), 1561-1591.
  55. Ozbilgin, M. (2008), “Global Diversity Management”, in Smith, P.B., Peterson, M.F. and Thomas, D.C. (eds.) The Handbook of Cross Cultural Management Research. Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
  56. Özbilgin M and Tatli A (2008), “Global Diversity Management: An Evidence-Based Approach”. Basingstoke and New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
  57. Özbilgin, M., and Tatli, A. (2011), “Mapping out the field of equality and diversity: Rise of individualism and voluntarism”. Human Relations, 64(9), 1229-1253.
  58. Phoenix, A. and Pattynama, P. (2006), “Editorial: Intersectionality”, European Journal of Women’s Studies, 13(3), 187–92.
  59. Pless, N. and Maak, T. (2004), “Building an inclusive diversity culture: Principles, processes and practice”, Journal of Business Ethics, 54(2), 129-147.
  60. Ragins, B. R., Cornwell, J. M. and Miller, J. S. (2003), “Heterosexism in the Workplace: Do Race And Gender Matter?”, Group & Organization Management, 28, 45-74.
  61. Rees, T. (2006), “Mainstreaming equality in the European Union”. Routledge.
  62. Rumens, N. (2012), “Queering cross-sex friendships: An analysis of gay and bisexual men’s workplace friendships with heterosexual women”, Human Relations, 65(8), 955-978.
  63. Rumens, N. (2010), “Firm friends: exploring the supportive components in gay men's workplace friendships”, The Sociological Review, 58(1), 135-155.
  64. Rumens, N. (2008), “Working at intimacy: gay men's workplace friendships”. Gender, Work & Organization, 15(1), 9-30.
  65. Sabharwal, M. (2014), “Is diversity management sufficient? Organizational inclusion to further performance”, Public Personnel Management, 43(2), 197-217.
  66. Schwindt-Bayer, L. and Squire, P. (2014), “Legislative Power and Women's Representation”, Politics & Gender, 10(4), 622-658.
  67. Shore, L. M., Chung-Herrera, B. G., Dean, M. A., Ehrhart, K. H., Jung, D. I., Randel, A. E., and Singh, G. (2009), “Diversity in organizations: where are we now and where are we going?”, Human Resource Management Review, 19(2), 117-133.
  68. Singal, M. and Gerde, V.W. (2015), “Is Diversity Management Related to Financial Performance in Family Firms?”, Family Business Review, 28(3), 243-259.
  69. Snell, M. (1979), “The Equal Pay and Sex Discrimination Acts: their impact in the workplace”, Feminist Review, 1(1), 37-57.
  70. Tatli, A. (2011), A multi‐layered exploration of the diversity management field: diversity discourses, practices and practitioners in the UK”, British Journal of Management, 22(2), 238-253.
  71. Taylor, Y. (2007), “If Your Face Doesn’t Fit…: The Misrecognition of Working‐Class Lesbians in Scene Space”. Leisure Studies, 26(2), 161-178.
  72. Taylor, T. (2003), “Diversity management in a multi-cultural society: An exploratory study of cultural diversity and team sport in Australia”, Annals of Leisure Research, 6(2), 168-188.
  73. Thomas, D.A. and Ely, R.J. (1996), “Making differences matter: A new paradigm for managing diversity”, Harvard Business Review, 74(5), 79-90.
  74. Windsor, L.C., Shorkey, C. and Battle, D. (2015), “Measuring student learning in social justice courses: The diversity and oppression scale”, Journal of Social Work Education, 51(1), 58-71.
  75. Woodhams, C. and Lupton, B. (2006a), “Gender-based equal opportunities policy and practice in small firms: The impact of HR professionals”. Human Resource Management Journal. 16(1), 74–97.
  76. Woodhams, C. and Lupton, B. (2006b), “Does size matter? Gender-based equal opportunity in UK small and medium enterprises”. Women in Management Review, 21(2), 143–69.
  77. Wrench, J. (2008), “Diversity management and discrimination: Immigrants and ethnic minorities in the EU”, Human Resource Management International Digest, 16(4).
  78. Wright, T. (2011), “A “lesbian advantage? Analysing the intersections of gender, sexuality and class in male dominated work”, Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, 30(8), 686-701.
  79. Zanoni, P. and Janssens, M. (2003), “Deconstructing Difference: The Rhetoric of Human Resource Managers’ Diversity Discourses”, Organization Studies. 25(1), 55– 74.
  80. Zanoni, P. and Janssens, M. (2007), “Minority Employees Engaging with (Diversity) Management: An Analysis of Control, Agency and Micro-Emancipation”, Journal of Management Studies, 44(8), 1371–97.
  81. Zanoni, P. (2011). “Diversity in the lean automobile factory: doing class through gender, disability and age”, Organization. 18(1), 105-127.